|
Article Directory
|
+ Authors
+ Articles
|
|
|
|
A New Paradigm to Address the High Cost of Vendor Qualification
Copyright (c) 2010-2012 Norm Howe
When FDA inspected a Heparin supplier, Shanghai No. 1 Biochemical and Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd., they thought they were seeing the real plant. It turned out that it was only a show facility. The real plant was a shadow plant located somewhere else. The US-FDA Warning Letter later stated, "The inspection revealed that the facility was not manufacturing, and did not appear to have ever manufactured, Heparin Sodium USP (or heparin sodium) for the U.S. market."
This case is similar to Baxter Pharmaceutical's experience with their Heparin supplier in 2008. The result of that deception was that hundreds of patients suffered life-threatening reactions like severe hypotension, low blood pressure and over 80 people died.
As of today there are more than 150 wrongful death cases filed against Baxter. The cost of defending itself in those suits in legal fees and employee time will be high to say the least. Even if Baxter were to win those cases, they would lose. The effort of an integrated supplier compliance program now seems small in hindsight.
Could this happen to you? How do you protect the quality of your product? What are FDA's expectations for supplier qualification? The Heparin experience shows that even an extreme onsite inspection won't necessarily reveal severe quality problems. How does one confirm that the supplier plant that you are inspecting is actually the one that supplies your company?
Some things to watch for, according to FDA, include discrepancies in date (e.g., compare when the materials arrived versus when production and testing were done) and if the facility happens to be "renovating" or "not manufacturing the day" you are there for your audit. You have to see the product being manufactured in action. You can also ask to see batch records and other documentation as proof the factory is indeed operational.
Does this solve the Show and Shadow supplier danger? No. Clearly it's not a full solution. And the fact is there is no sure solution. It's very difficult to detect someone who is determined to commit fraud. You as a buyer need to be sure that you have located the actual production facility. Fortunately these instances are rare, and most suppliers at least try to produce a quality product.
But this incident shows how critical a supplier's quality program can be. The message is that even intensive on-site audits cannot find major vendor problems. 'Show and Shadow' is just an extreme example.
Although FDA's suggestions are certainly valuable, they and all the other responses to the increasing concerns over vendor quality all seem to say one thing: more intensive audits. More intensive audits, of course, mean higher costs. And as we have seen even an intensive audit isn't guaranteed to find all the problems at a supplier. The problem is that audits are only a snapshot; a surface skim at a point in time.
Any pharmaceutical or medical device plant is a very complex place. Unless you plan to take up residence at the vendor you have no chance to understand the true nature of these operations. And what company in today's cost-cutting climate has the resources to do that? Keep in mind that an audit costs more than what you pay for your auditors to investigate the vendor. The vendor has to spend their time escorting the auditors around, digging out records, and following up on action items. Guess who has to cover that cost. The assumption today is that a BETTER audit means a LONGER audit. There has to be another way.
What's needed is a new paradigm for vendor qualification; a tool that can drill deeply into the vendor's operation at low cost; something that can provide a more lasting measure of the vendor's performance than simply an audit.
To get to the solution we have to answer this question, why don't vendors always comply with the regulations. My answer, based on years of auditing and operations management, is that by far the most common reason is lack of knowledge of the regulations through-out the organization. I'm not talking here about a general understanding of requirements. I mean a deep Knowledge of the details of how to comply with the regulations - not just that the packaging room needs to be inspected before packaging operations begin; but that previous materials have been removed, packaging and labeling materials inspected, extraneous materials removed, documentation, etc.
Sure, there is generally someone in most vendor organizations who knows the regulations. But in poorly performing companies the attitude is often that regulatory compliance is up to the Quality Department.
My proposition is that once everyone in an organization KNOWS the regulations as they apply to their jobs, DOING the job right is straightforward. The biggest hurdle to overcome is disseminating detailed Knowledge of what needs to be done to all the employees.
How can one use this relationship to assist with the problem of supplier qualification? What if it were possible to objectively measure what all the employees of a supplier know about GMPs? That deep Knowledge plus a broad snapshot of the supplier based on an audit will give you a strong measurement of the supplier's performance.
The next question is how does one measure that Knowledge. Knowledge is not so easily measured in an audit. You can check training records. Usually you will see who sat through what training class, or who was checked off as proficient in on-the-job training. There is rarely any indication of what people actually KNOW.
So how could we effectively measure the Knowledge of all of a supplier's employees? Well, technology gives us an edge today that didn't exist not too long ago. Computer Based Training provides a reliable, and relatively cheap way to assure that all employees have a minimum skill level. Online GMP courses train and test any employee who has access to the internet. Learning Management Systems track who knows what, and make the results easily visible to management.
If you as a customer insist that suppliers test their employees and provide you with verification that all their employees have passed their GMP courses, then you can have a high degree of confidence that the supplier has the Knowledge to make compliant products. You as a customer can have independent access to the training verification reports. When your auditors cross-check the training reports against the names on batch records, the vendor suddenly becomes completely transparent.
There's another advantage when everyone in an organization is passing the same tests, peer pressure. It's not easy for one person to bypass a GMP requirement when everyone around knows that it's the wrong thing to do.
Requiring your vendor to give their employees online, verified GMP training insures that they have a deep Knowledge of the regulations. This doesn't really cost any incremental money because this is something the vendor should be doing anyway. Combining the visibility of an online Computer Based Training system with an audit can make your supplier's quality program truly transparent.
|
Norm Howe, Senior Partner at Validation and Compliance Institute, consultants for the pharmaceutical and medical device industries. He got his BS at UC, Berkeley, and a Ph.D. in chemistry at UCLA. He has held many management positions in FDA regulated industries, most at BASF. http://www.vcillc.com/
|
Follow "The Phantom Writers" on Twitter
(@phantomwriters)
to be notified when new articles are made available.
VOTE ON THIS ARTICLE
Needs Work >>
0 -
1 -
2 -
3 -
4 -
5
<< Excellent Article
Tell our authors what you think about their article.
|
Top-Level Category: Business Offline Articles || Related Categories: Business Online Articles
10 Most Recent Articles Written by Norm Howe
Where Will FDA Target Next? What IVD Manufacturers Should Know Before Their Next FDA Audit
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2011-09-12 |
Word Count: 706 |
Page Views: 353
Medical device manufacturers are always interested in knowing
what FDA's next area of focus will be. Well, if you're an In
Vitro Diagnostic manufacturer you might review your measurement
systems.
How to Evaluate the Quality of a Dietary Supplement
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2010-11-02 |
Word Count: 751 |
Page Views: 995
| Votes: 3 |
Rating: 0.67
So, you've found a Dietary Supplement that exactly fits
your special need. The information on the supplier's
website appears to be consistent with everything that
you've read and heard, and now you're ready to buy. But
there are questions on your mind. "What is the quality of
this product that I'm buying?" you ask. "Can I really
trust this supplier?"
Off-Label Use of Medical Devices
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2010-06-22 |
Word Count: 621 |
Page Views: 1213
How can a medical practitioner decide whether a medical device
that they want to use for one of their patients is legal and
approved by the Food and Drug Administration? When a patient
comes into a physician's office the patient is looking for the
best, most modern care they can get. And a physician certainly
wants the same thing.
FDA's New Process Validation Guidance Recommends Team Approach
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2009-03-10 |
Word Count: 666 |
Page Views: 1731
| Votes: 7 |
Rating: 0.86
The November 2008 FDA draft guidance for process validation says
"We recommend an integrated team approach to process validation
that includes expertise from a variety of disciplines..." But
when different people from different backgrounds work together,
disagreements can stall your team. How do you get your project
back on track?
The Myth of the Generic SOP
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2009-03-03 |
Word Count: 687 |
Page Views: 1263
| Votes: 6 |
Rating: 2.50
What do you do when your boss tells you to write an SOP? Run and
hide? Tell her how long it will really take to write one that's
any good? If you choose the latter option, be prepared for this
"helpful suggestion": "Why don't you just download a generic
SOP from the internet?" You would have been better off taking
the former option. Here's why.
The Evolution of Process Validation
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2009-01-27 |
Word Count: 471 |
Page Views: 2675
| Votes: 13 |
Rating: 1.69
In November 2008, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
published draft guidance on process validation. Entitled Process
Validation: General Principles and Practices, this draft guidance
replaces the previous guidance issued in 1987. What does this
mean to you?
FDA's New Process Validation Guidance Recommends Team Approach
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2009-01-21 |
Word Count: 665 |
Page Views: 2517
| Votes: 6 |
Rating: 3.83
The November 2008 FDA draft guidance for process validation says
"We recommend an integrated team approach to process validation
that includes expertise from a variety of disciplines..." But
when different people from different backgrounds work together,
disagreements can stall your team. How do you get your project
back on track?
Proposed FDA Compliance Guide to Assist Small Dietary Supplement Manufacturers
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2009-01-05 |
Word Count: 440 |
Page Views: 1070
| Votes: 4 |
Rating: 2.50
How do small Dietary Supplement manufacturers comply with the new
Dietary Supplement GMPs? The U.S. Food and Drug Administration
(FDA) announced plans to publish a compliance guide that will
provide assistance to small dietary supplement manufacturers.
Dietary Supplements Must Be Tested by Scientifically Valid Methods
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2008-09-03 |
Word Count: 424 |
Page Views: 1348
| Votes: 6 |
Rating: 1.00
Are you a Dietary Supplement manufacturer trying to figure out
what FDA means by "Scientifically Valid Method"? Here are some
hints.
FDA Cracks Down on Fake Cures
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2008-08-14 |
Word Count: 406 |
Page Views: 1780
| Votes: 15 |
Rating: 2.00
In an effort to crack down on charlatans who prey on the sick,
the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recently issued
warning letters to 23 U.S. companies and two foreign individuals
marketing a wide range of products that fraudulently claim to
prevent and cure cancer.
All of Author's Articles on this site: Norm Howe Articles
Most Recent "Business Offline" Articles
How To Build a Strong and Powerful Business During a Recession
Written by: Trey McMartin |
Distributed: 2011-11-10 |
Word Count: 987 |
Page Views: 465
During a recession, most business owners pull the reins on
advertising budgets, fearful of what tomorrow might bring...
Those who remain fearful have forgotten what made them the
success they are today... They have forgotten that they have
a God-given talent to overcome the incredible obstacles in
their paths.
SEO Lessons from Local Businesses
Written by: Trey McMartin |
Distributed: 2011-11-09 |
Word Count: 945 |
Page Views: 869
More than once in the six years that I have been providing
SEO services for websites, I have had the opportunity to
discuss with individual business owners their search engine
optimization needs. Now and again, I run across an
individual business owner who is quick to say that SEO is
absolutely worthless. When confronted with such an absolute
statement, I like to press for details. It has been my
experience that people who speak in negative absolutes will
have a horror story to share.
Where Will FDA Target Next? What IVD Manufacturers Should Know Before Their Next FDA Audit
Written by: Norm Howe |
Distributed: 2011-09-12 |
Word Count: 706 |
Page Views: 353
Medical device manufacturers are always interested in knowing
what FDA's next area of focus will be. Well, if you're an In
Vitro Diagnostic manufacturer you might review your measurement
systems.
Online Fax - 10 Reasons To Get An Online Fax Service
Written by: Titus Hoskins |
Distributed: 2011-09-12 |
Word Count: 560 |
Page Views: 366
Online faxing is the new more modern way to fax. If you or your
company is not using an online fax service, here are 10 good
reasons why you should get it.
Best Effort Essential for the Job Interview
Written by: Barbara Wulf MS, ACC, CPCC |
Distributed: 2011-07-30 |
Word Count: 676 |
Page Views: 445
Interviewing will determine if you are the right person for the
job. These tips will help you make the job interview a success.
Go Green With Your Career Search
Written by: Barbara Wulf MS, ACC, CPCC |
Distributed: 2011-07-28 |
Word Count: 636 |
Page Views: 361
Many of the qualities of green living, like recycling and
sustainability, can apply to a career search, even if the
career is not directly associated with green industries.
ReCareer in the Second-half of Life
Written by: Barbara Wulf MS, ACC, CPCC |
Distributed: 2011-07-26 |
Word Count: 525 |
Page Views: 423
| Votes: 1 |
Rating: 3.00
Many of us worked the first half of our life to "fit" the
job description. ReCareering is about finding the right fit,
being selective, being creative, being fulfilled and being
intentional about how you spend your time.
Up in the Air
Written by: Barbara Wulf MS, ACC, CPCC |
Distributed: 2011-07-24 |
Word Count: 678 |
Page Views: 426
When looking for work or changing careers, go beyond researching
on the internet and reading articles. Find out how you can learn
from the art of listening and having a conversation.
Salon and Spa Owners: Which Monk Are You?
Written by: Dan Lok |
Distributed: 2011-07-05 |
Word Count: 477 |
Page Views: 462
Too many salon and spa owners are carrying around a lot
hurts, regrets, guilt, past failures and fears about the
future. But no one is forcing you to carry these emotional
rocks, so put that sack down!
The Single Most Profitable Day You Spend on Your Spa or Salon!
Written by: Dan Lok |
Distributed: 2011-06-30 |
Word Count: 470 |
Page Views: 567
Salon and spa owners need to combine their marketing plan
with marketing systems. A marketing calendar plans out
strategies for a year, and is instrumental to the success of
your spa or salon.
Most Viewed "Business Offline" Articles
How To Write A 300 Page Book In Four Months
Written by: Mark Silver |
Distributed: 2008-07-15 |
Word Count: 821 |
Page Views: 36740
| Votes: 6 |
Rating: 1.83
There's a lot of hoopla about becoming an author of your very
own business book. The promise of fame and fortune is very
alluring. Yet your book remains perpetually 'about to be'
written. Meanwhile your business has ground to a halt. Hmmm...
might there be a better way to get a book written?
The Best Marketing Book I've Ever Read (You'll Be Surprised)
Written by: Judy Murdoch |
Distributed: 2007-05-09 |
Word Count: 1522 |
Page Views: 33878
| Votes: 15 |
Rating: 3.60
From time to time someone asks me to recommend marketing books.
Here's one of my favorite marketing books that always surprises
people. Curious? Read on.
The Bizarre History Of The HOLLYWOOD Sign
Written by: Morris Timlen |
Distributed: 2008-11-05 |
Word Count: 1211 |
Page Views: 28586
| Votes: 22 |
Rating: 3.32
The most famous sign in the history of mankind is the one that
graces the side of the hill above Hollywood, California. As
famous a landmark as the Christ the Redeemer statue in Rio De
Janeiro, the Eiffel Tower in Paris France, the Great Pyramid of
Giza in Egypt, The Church of the Savior on Blood in Saint
Petersburg Russia, and the Statue Of Liberty in New York City,
the Hollywood sign is known around the world as the symbol of the
American movie industry.
What Does It Take To Be A Successful Salesman?
Written by: Casey Moher |
Distributed: 2008-08-05 |
Word Count: 930 |
Page Views: 16087
| Votes: 68 |
Rating: 3.16
In the course of my average workweek, I meet people who tell me
that they have no sales experience, and very literally, many
will tell me that they could not sell if their lives depended on
it. Do you fit into this mold? Do you seriously believe that you
can sell me on the idea that you cannot sell things?
Selecting Between a 401(k) And 403(b) For a Nonprofit
Written by: Daniel Lamaute |
Distributed: 2007-10-11 |
Word Count: 333 |
Page Views: 6839
| Votes: 17 |
Rating: 2.65
Newly released IRS regulations impose several new requirements
and fiduciary responsibilities on employers with 403(b) plans.
While the regulations generally don't take effect until January
1, 2009, there are some provisions that apply sooner.
Pitch A No-Hitter With Baseball-Themed Flower Gifts
Written by: Wesley Berry, AAF |
Distributed: 2007-12-25 |
Word Count: 413 |
Page Views: 6112
| Votes: 16 |
Rating: 1.94
Want to send a gift to the baseball fan in your life that's sure
to knock one out of the park? Send flowers with a baseball
theme! Everyone loves flowers and when you personalize them to
include the recipient's favorite hobbies, like baseball,
they're sure to make an even greater impression.
Never Write A 'Thank You' Letter Again
Written by: Perry Maisin |
Distributed: 2008-08-12 |
Word Count: 971 |
Page Views: 5867
| Votes: 17 |
Rating: 2.29
When I was in graduate school, I had a friend who interviewed at
fortune 500 companies and succeeded at landing a great job. One
day, I saw him sitting in the student union with a stack of
cards. The cards said 'thank you'. He opened each card and
signed his name. The inside of the card was blank. I asked him
what he was doing and he told me that it was important to send a
'thank you' to every person you interviewed with. He believed
that that was the difference between getting the job and being
passed over.
Conducting Effective Career Aspiration Discussions with Employees
Written by: Andria L. Corso |
Distributed: 2010-03-10 |
Word Count: 690 |
Page Views: 5332
| Votes: 8 |
Rating: 1.88
Enhance your talent management and development programs
through conducting career aspiration discussions with your
employees. Find out where they want to grow their career to
determine if it matches your business needs. This will
enable you to differentiate your employee development to
grow the future leaders of your company.
The Pros And Cons Of Postcard Marketing-direct marketing offline
Written by: Cheryl Miller |
Distributed: 2006-11-29 |
Word Count: 675 |
Page Views: 3998
| Votes: 5 |
Rating: 2.60
Postcard marketing is one of the oldest methods of marketing. Its
concept is simple but can be quite effective. It is just sending
out your message to your mailing list on a postcard. Postcard
marketing is a powerful and cost effective way to advertise and
will keep building in momentum when done correctly.
The Tea Room Business Plan – First Steps And Start Up Basics
Written by: Marcus Stout |
Distributed: 2007-03-22 |
Word Count: 1218 |
Page Views: 3703
| Votes: 19 |
Rating: 2.63
Every venture starts with the first steps and a business plan for
a quality tea room is no exception. Well thought out first steps,
properly implemented, will pay dividends in the business
operations of the tea room in later years.
Highest Ranked "Business Offline" Articles
Why Businesses Need Receivable Factoring In Cash Flow Management
Written by: Toby Seibert |
Distributed: 2007-08-08 |
Word Count: 866 |
Page Views: 1886
| Votes: 5 |
Rating: 4.60
In today's business environment, many businesses need to
fine-tune the process of getting paid on invoices, in order to
improve their cash on hand. Improving cash flow can be an ongoing
challenge for businesses of all sizes, and it is an issue that
must be addressed to ensure the long-term viability of the
business.
Whose Restaurant Can You Find Online?
Written by: Rudy Vener |
Distributed: 2007-07-09 |
Word Count: 640 |
Page Views: 1550
| Votes: 5 |
Rating: 4.40
What is so significant about Pizza Hut's latest TV commercial?
Business School for Non-Business Minds: Got a NAICS Number?
Written by: Melissa Mashtonio |
Distributed: 2008-04-15 |
Word Count: 423 |
Page Views: 1637
| Votes: 5 |
Rating: 4.40
I’m a journalist. I spent a lot of my career in the news
business. As my career has progressed, I’ve spent time at small
and large companies, and I have sat through dozens of business
meetings wondering what the heck the “money” people are talking
about. They used acronyms as if they were a foreign language.
The Problem With Swiping Sales Copy
Written by: Scott Bywater |
Distributed: 2009-12-03 |
Word Count: 480 |
Page Views: 1062
| Votes: 5 |
Rating: 4.40
This is what people miss when they try to simply "swipe"
sales copy from another advertisement.
Equal Opportunity Pizza Ordering
Written by: Rudy Vener |
Distributed: 2007-10-19 |
Word Count: 629 |
Page Views: 1546
| Votes: 8 |
Rating: 4.38
With online ordering, your menu and restaurant suddenly become
accessible to both the deaf and blind customers in your
community.
The Secret To Making Successful Business Connections
Written by: Kate Smalley |
Distributed: 2006-10-11 |
Word Count: 672 |
Page Views: 1660
| Votes: 6 |
Rating: 4.00
If you have a hard time making successful business connections,
don't despair. Anyone can be good at meeting people-if they use
the right technique. The whole secret to making a positive
connection is knowing how to attract people and inspire them to
want to give you a chance.
How to Build a Really Great Business? (Super Success Secrets from a Legendary Business Master)
Written by: Chet Holmes |
Distributed: 2007-01-15 |
Word Count: 1523 |
Page Views: 1647
| Votes: 7 |
Rating: 4.00
Times are tough. The economy is in a constant state of upheaval.
Is your company doing better than most? Are you placing greater
emphasis on pure performance?
Get the Balance Right
Written by: Rich Thawley |
Distributed: 2009-01-28 |
Word Count: 638 |
Page Views: 1499
| Votes: 11 |
Rating: 3.91
Do you build your business around your family or your family
around your business? The choice is yours.
Online Copywriting Makes Content as the King
Written by: Steven Gerber |
Distributed: 2006-12-11 |
Word Count: 560 |
Page Views: 1671
| Votes: 7 |
Rating: 3.86
The inverted pyramid is basically the placing of 4 W's in the
primary sentences of the articles, supported by the other W and H
on the following discussions. Four W's consist of what, when,
where, and who. The other W which stands for why on the other
hand, follows on the succeeding paragraphs, including the
elaboration for the H which also stands for how, if necessary.
Interview Coaching: A Home-Based Business on the Cutting Edge
Written by: Carole Martin |
Distributed: 2007-08-24 |
Word Count: 1400 |
Page Views: 1412
| Votes: 7 |
Rating: 3.86
You name it - Blackberry, Skype Connection, Cell Phone, iPhone -
these are the tools of this trade. Who would believe that someone
with a home-based business could reach out to someone in a far
away country and work with a client via a Blackberry and a cell
phone?
|
|
|
Article Reprint Rights
|
This work is
licensed under a
Creative Commons
License
You are not required to show the creative commons license notice when you reprint this work.
|
|
Article Statistics
|
Word Count: 1160
Total Views: 912
Views This Month: 36
Views Last Month: 46
Article Rating: 1.50 of 5
Votes Cast: 4
Author Overall Stats:
Times Viewed Overall: 29338
Author Rating: 2.14 of 5
Votes Cast Overall: 116
More Articles By Author:
Articles On This Website
Article Title Search:
Widow Search
Right Blinker
Google
Yahoo!
Zuula
Bing
Cuil
Last Distribution Date:
2010-01-12 13:00:00
|
|
|
Home
for Writers
for Publishers
Article Directory
Article Search
Contact
Get RSS Feed
