|
Article Directory
|
+ Authors
+ Articles
|
|
|
|
A Comparison of Tattoo Removal Methods: Tattoo Removal Skin Peels Vs Tattoo Removal Creams Vs Tattoo Removal Using DermaBrasion
Copyright (c) 2009-2012 Abe Granberry
A friend and I, along with 3 other buddies, decided to try an experiment to remove tattoos that we have all had for many years. Over time we just decided we no longer liked what we saw on our arms, shoulders and chest so we decided to test all the varieties of tattoo removal except Laser because none of us could afford the price, plus we wanted to see for ourselves if the other products actually worked or were just marketing hype. We represent a mix of 2 Civil Engineers, a Commercial Real Estate salesman, a pharmaceutical sales rep and a self employed landscape architect.
After reviewing the options available we decided to use Tat B Gone and Tattoo-Off (http://tattoo-off.com/) to represent the tattoo removal creams, Nuviderm (http://www.nuviderm.com/) to represent the cosmetic acid peeling agents and WreckingBalm (http://wreckingbalm.com/) as the dermabrasion candidate. We didn't even consider a salt dermabrasion product because I had used a brand that shall remain nameless and I could have gotten the same results using 80 grit sandpaper, man was it rough.
We had 5 guinea pigs and 4 products so it was decided to really test the tattoo removal creams since, if they worked, it would be the obvious way to go since you just rub it on like Jergins Hand lotion and after a few months you're done, or so we thought, but we'll get to that later.
Since this whole thing was my idea I decided to use WreckingBalm. I've heard the radio commercials and it sounded like the way to go. Robert, Khalid and Pat started with TatBGone and Tattoo-Off and George was the Nuviderm test subject. Mind you, two of these guys, Robert and Khalid were the Engineers - and they were driving us nuts with observing proper technique, following instructions to the "T" and keeping logs with application dates, results etc. They wanted quantifiable results at the end of the test to make sure THEY were satisfied that the winner was actually the best product.
The official kickoff for the test was at my house. We sat around the island in the kitchen, read the instructions and proceeded to do our first tattoo removal treatments. None of us had what I would call huge tats, just run of the mill stuff - names (2), a Celtic symbol that we kidded George was the symbol for Idiot, a flag and a weird conglomeration of an ex-wife's name covered up by what was supposed to be the Arkansas Razorback mascot, which we all took to be symbolic for a nasty divorce.
The tattoo cream guys had it easy, they just rubbed a little on their tattoos, popped open a beer and watched George and I go through the steps of our chosen removal methods. I had my battery operated sander, spray, cream - the whole nine yards. I knew I picked a winner and was happy with the entire procedure that first day, while George was next to me bitchin about diluting, mixing and testing, but was determined to get rid of that Celtic symbol.
When I finished my skin was red from sanding on it, maybe a bit to eager my first time out. George was showing off his "Frost" which meant his first Nuviderm application was a success and wasn't actually all that bad.
If this was a movie this is the part where they would flash on the screen ...ONE MONTH LATER...
The cream guys - Robert, Khalid and Pat had been rubbing away for 30 days - their tattoos looked the same, but they now had soft skin! I had been grinding away every third day, spraying and rubbing as instructed with nothing to show, but it was still early and we all knew going in this was a long term project - at least 6 months, maybe a year (but hopefully not). George had peeled a layer of skin and had done his second application the previous week so his skin was about to peel again, but no real change as far as we could tell.
...TWO MONTHS INTO THE TEST...
The Tat B Gone and Tattoo-off guys were still rubbing and one was starting to see a bit of difference, but nothing to brag about.
George was still peeling, his third application the day before with no noticeable change and I was still sanding and using the other stuff, but every third day seemed to harsh, my skin was a bit tender so occasionally I'd have to skip a day and sand on the fourth day. Still no change.
90 DAYS INTO THE TEST...
Tattoo creams weren't doing much, but Khalid's skin color was fading but not his tattoo, it was weird. Khalid has a dark brown complexion, but it was a lighter brown where he had been rubbing on the cream with no noticeable change to the tattoo. Robert and Pat couldn't see any difference to skin tone or tattoo.
George was about to do his fourth treatment, his skin was slightly pink at the treated area and the tattoo seemed to be getting brighter, more vivid. Not what we expected, but he was prepared to continue.
I was still sanding away and couldn't tell for sure if there was a difference or not, but I was undeterred.
...Four Months...
Again the guys using the tattoo creams, Tat B Gone and Tattoo-Off, were showing no progress, but Khalid was developing a light brown spot on his shoulder where his tattoo was located, but the tattoo wasn't changing, it had to be the skin lightening chemical in the cream working on his skin pigment but not the tattoo ink. We were seeing that the product reduced skin pigment color but so far had no effect on tattoo ink. On a positive note, they all had soft skin!!
George had slightly increased the strength of the Nuviderm solution he was using and was beginning to see slight but definite changes in his tattoo.
I was still doing the sanding regimen, but it was becoming something of a nuisance because of the frequency of the treatments, but there was progress being made, however slight it was.
Five Months
Tattoo cream guys - nothing except for Khalid with his light brown spot and unchanged tattoo.
George, using Nuviderm, was now making some real progress. You could see that the tattoo ink was not all deposited at the same depth because he had spots showing where the ink had been removed and areas where there was still ink - he now had a spotted Celtic symbol which was a sign of real progress. His skin was pinkish at the treated area, but after all he was peeling his skin about once every 4 weeks and it was working.
I was making some headway with WreckingBalm but not as much as George and the WreckingBalm had cost four times as much as the Nuviderm so on the Return On Investment George was the clear winner at this point.
Six Months
The tattoo removal cream guys, Pat and Robert, had soft skin, but no change in their tattoos and I could tell Khalid and I were cousins because his light brown spot was now about the color of my skin, but the tattoo was very clearly unchanged.
If this was a horse race, George was clearly pulling away, leading the pack by a full length maybe a bit more. The spots cleared of ink were getting bigger and the remaining ink was very definitely lighter in color.
I was making progress, clearly WreckingBalm was working, but not as fast as Nuviderm and it required more work and cost four times as much. We were beginning to see a winner, but the race was not quite finished.
Seven Months Into the Test
At this point it was obvious the tattoo removal creams were not working and the cost of the products was money down a rat hole.
Georges' Celtic Symbol was a happily fading memory and I was fading my tat but the cost and effort was clearly not worth it when compared to the tremendous progress George had made with Nuviderm.
Month Eight ...And we have a Winner...
The tattoo cream guys had given up and Khalid wanted to lose the light spot on his skin.
Georges tattoo was still there, but it's days were numbered. His progress with Nuviderm was so far ahead of Wreckingbalm it was pathetic and all for only $40.
WreckingBalm was working, but it was so slow, so regimented and so expensive compared to Nuviderm that we declared Nuviderm the winner by unanimous consent.
The final results were striking and somewhat surprising, at least to me. I thought for sure WreckingBalm would win, but for all their advertising they were second best to the clear winner Nuviderm. I have stopped sanding my skin and with Georges help I'm going to do my first Nuviderm treatment as soon as my order arrives. Doing a treatment once a month or so beats 3 times a week in my book.
Final recommendation - Nuviderm won - it wasn't even close.
Nuviderm Review - 5 thumbs up! (http://www.nuviderm.com/)
*** One final note, as I was finishing up this article I came across a site called HealthySkinAssociation.org that in the bullet point section of the home page brought up some interesting points on how to decide on which tattoo removal products to try and which to avoid.
Quoting from the Healthy Skin Association:
"In recent years there has been a proliferation of tattoo removal creams, most of which promise more than they deliver. There are a few basic guidelines one should use when researching which tattoo removal method best suits their circumstance and in determining which manufacturers they can trust.
Does the basic product have a history of successfully removing tattoos?
Does the manufacturer offer a reasonable product guarantee?
Can the product be returned after using or does using the product void the guarantee?
Always follow product instructions for use.
Does the manufacturer offer full disclosure on the ingredients of their product?
Does the product, if a cream, contain Hydroquinone, a known cancer causing agent?
Does the product, if a cream, contain more than just a recipe for fading skin pigment?
Pigment faders have never been proven to fade or remove tattoo ink.
If choosing laser removal make sure the laser equipment is of high quality and latest generation to insure proper removal of the various shades of green, yellow, and blue.
Ask the laser clinic about a guarantee or escrow policy to insure you that you get what you pay for.
Know which wavelengths of laser light remove the colors of your tattoo and make sure your clinic has the necessary equipment.
Ask about topical anesthesia to ease the pain of laser removal."
That is very common sense advise that I wish we would have thought about before we started our test.
|
Abe Granberry has been working as a tattoo artist for the last 15 years. In that time, he has learned that tattoos to cover up other tattoos are usually a bad idea. Read more of Abe's articles at: http://myinformationdigest.com/ Abe would like to credit the http://healthyskinassociation.org/ for providing an additional bit of common sense when searching for laser and do it your self tattoo removal products.
|
Follow "The Phantom Writers" on Twitter
(@phantomwriters)
to be notified when new articles are made available.
VOTE ON THIS ARTICLE
Needs Work >>
0 -
1 -
2 -
3 -
4 -
5
<< Excellent Article
Tell our authors what you think about their article.
|
Top-Level Category: Health and Wellness Articles || Related Categories: Shopping Articles
10 Most Recent Articles Written by Abe Granberry
Most Recent "Health And Wellness" Articles
The Powerful Antioxidant You Cannot Eat Or Drink
Written by: Nate Rifkin |
Distributed: 2011-07-20 |
Word Count: 499 |
Page Views: 591
There's no need to eat or drink anything to activate your
body's powerful antioxidant to prevent free radical damage.
You'll end up healthier inside and looking better on the outside
as well.
3 Bacterial Vaginosis Remedies You Can Start Using Today
Written by: Louise Endago |
Distributed: 2011-07-20 |
Word Count: 867 |
Page Views: 647
Very few women are successful at treating bacterial
vaginosis using one treatment alone. The secret lies in
using a combination of treatments that complement one
another. In this article you will discover 3 such remedies
that give excellent results.
Encouraging Healthy Children with Outdoor Play Sets and Activities
Written by: Giana Briggs |
Distributed: 2011-03-17 |
Word Count: 410 |
Page Views: 866
Having a play set in your backyard can be a great way to get
your child off the couch and out into the fresh air. With
childhood obesity on the rise, we need to do what we can as
parents to get our children active and enjoying playing and
interacting with each other children again. Being able to go
out in the yard and have something to do is just one small
step in the right direction.
How to Recognize Anxiety in Children and Adolescents
Written by: Dr Jeannette Kavanagh |
Distributed: 2010-12-28 |
Word Count: 836 |
Page Views: 916
Problems with a too-high level anxiety can start in
childhood with children and adolescents worrying to a
greater extent than their peers about all sorts of things.
Some behaviors are an indication of a fussy and over tidy
child. When we go just a little bit over fussiness and we
have entered the realm of an anxiety disorder.
How to Tell if You Have Anxiety Disorder
Written by: Dr Jeannette Kavanagh |
Distributed: 2010-12-23 |
Word Count: 1093 |
Page Views: 910
If you're someone who can never earn enough or have enough
money to relax about it, and to enjoy spending it, you may
have underlying anxiety problems that you haven't had to
face, or you haven't wanted to face.
How to Tell the Difference Between Anxiety and Normal Worry
Written by: Dr Jeannette Kavanagh |
Distributed: 2010-12-21 |
Word Count: 979 |
Page Views: 775
Anxiety is a normal feeling people experience when faced
with threat, danger or stress. Feeling anxious can sometimes
be a good thing. Occasional anxiety is part of normal life.
However, for some people anxiety is a constant factor in
their lives. When a person has anxiety problems, it
interferes with their ability to function normally on a
daily basis. Anxiety disorder can cause people to feel
intense, long-lasting fear or worry, in addition to other
symptoms.
How to Treat Your Anxiety and Panic Attacks
Written by: Dr Jeannette Kavanagh |
Distributed: 2010-12-16 |
Word Count: 742 |
Page Views: 895
| Votes: 2 |
Rating: 2.50
Next to Depression, one of the most common disorders which
affects an estimated 2.4 million people in America alone, is
anxiety disorder. Anxiety can manifest as a generalized
anxiety, panic attacks, social anxiety and agoraphobia.
Anxiety disorder can be mild or so totally disabling that
the person is confined to her or his home. All forms of
anxiety can be extremely frightening to those who experience
it frequently, but many individuals have found comfort in
the fact that anxiety disorders can be treated.
Anxiety Disorder and Panic Attacks: How Cognitive Behavior Therapy Can Help You
Written by: Dr Jeannette Kavanagh |
Distributed: 2010-12-09 |
Word Count: 748 |
Page Views: 871
In your journey to conquer anxiety and to eliminate panic
attacks from your day-to-day life, no one approach will be
totally right, but Cognitive Behavior Therapy can be a very
powerful part of your recovery. In this short article, I
want to explore what's involved in Cognitive Behavior
Therapy, so that you can make a decision whether or not
you'd like to explore it with your therapist.
Losing Weight - The Addiction of Comfort Food
Written by: Larry Tobin |
Distributed: 2010-11-04 |
Word Count: 863 |
Page Views: 1288
| Votes: 1 |
Rating: 0.00
Its very name is appealing - comfort food. What could be
more wonderful than a food that helps us feel better? Almost
everyone can name something that they eat when they're just
feeling sour or sad. Of course, we know that food can't be
the solution to our problems, especially the problem of
trying to lose weight and keep it off. So why do we find
ourselves trapped in the eat/feel better/feel worse/eat some
more cycle?
Understanding the Roles of Respite Caregivers for Seniors
Written by: Bob Fischer |
Distributed: 2010-11-02 |
Word Count: 582 |
Page Views: 974
Caregivers for seniors are typically paid providers but they
may also be volunteers from a government or nonprofit
organization. Where care is being provided in the home there
is often a mix of formal and informal care provided. And the
trend is towards using more formal care since, unlike the
past, more informal respite caregivers are employed. Read
on.
Most Viewed "Health And Wellness" Articles
Bone Density and Your Well Being
Written by: Kamau Austin |
Distributed: 2006-06-15 |
Word Count: 685 |
Page Views: 47774
| Votes: 39 |
Rating: 2.69
We spend a lot of time and energy thinking of ways to reduce our
weight but we need to think about the bones that form the basic
structure of the very same body. Bone density is an important
factor in helping us stay young and on our toes. Bone density
needs to be checked as we age and if found low, adequate measures
need to be taken to improve it.
Losing Weight Without Gaining Stretch Marks
Written by: Kamau Austin |
Distributed: 2006-12-11 |
Word Count: 579 |
Page Views: 15076
| Votes: 37 |
Rating: 2.78
Few things can make us as elated as seeing the pounds melt way
through our efforts of eating less and exercising more. We gain
new confidence and vitality as we watch our waistlines reappear
and become reacquainted with the tops of our feet. But as the
weight falls away we can be plagued by a new assault - one we did
not see coming - stretch marks.
President Given the Cure for Herpes and Cold Sores ?
Written by: James Kaylon McIntyre |
Distributed: 2006-11-09 |
Word Count: 404 |
Page Views: 13176
| Votes: 14 |
Rating: 2.57
Viraway was founded by a man who is in his 70s today. As a Young
man he suffered from acute cold sores. The discomfort was so
severe that he thought they would never go away. A native
American Indian gave him a tribal mixture of herbs and told him
that this mixture would eliminate the cold sores with in two
weeks...
Oyster Extract Improves Men's Sexual Health
Written by: Stephen Kavanagh |
Distributed: 2008-06-26 |
Word Count: 851 |
Page Views: 12419
| Votes: 38 |
Rating: 3.45
Description of the benefits of taking oyster extract powder for
good sexual health in men and women. Details of the features and
benefits, the different brands, the alternatives and advice on
choosing the right oyster extract product.
Is Retinol Good for Your Skin?
Written by: Craig Elliott |
Distributed: 2007-10-04 |
Word Count: 576 |
Page Views: 11125
| Votes: 26 |
Rating: 2.62
These days, whether you have wrinkles or you are certain that you
will get them in the near future, it is hard to ignore the
hundreds of new anti aging products on the market. With retinol
and AHAs, BHAs and vitamins, it's hard to tell which products
are actually going to work and which ones are will not. While a
lot of the success rate depends on the unique qualities of your
skin, there are scientific studies that have shed light some of
the more popular skin treatments.
Two years after 60 Minutes - Is Authentic Hoodia Available?
Written by: Dan Nessel |
Distributed: 2006-10-25 |
Word Count: 733 |
Page Views: 11010
| Votes: 9 |
Rating: 3.22
In November of 2004, 60 Minutes praised Hoodia Gordonii for its
ability to suppress appetite. Within days of the segement,
everyone and their mother were claiming to have "real" hoodia
for sale. The question remains - is any authenic Hoodia
available?
Causes for Yellow or Dark Brown Poop - Symptoms of Healthy Poop - Dr Oz's Tips to Diagnosis Yourself and Self Help
Written by: John Khu |
Distributed: 2009-12-29 |
Word Count: 545 |
Page Views: 9054
| Votes: 15 |
Rating: 2.27
Now the question arises how to detox your body? Body toxins
are accumulated due to improper food consumption; sedentary
lifestyle also causes digestion problem and heavy metal
toxins to accumulate in our body. Therefore, in order to
avoid bowel problem, your body needs to heavy metal detox.
Flax Oil And Gynecomastia
Written by: Will Brink |
Distributed: 2006-06-06 |
Word Count: 678 |
Page Views: 8679
| Votes: 19 |
Rating: 2.53
Q: Dear Will, I remember in your book "Priming the Anabolic
Environment" you recommended flax oil as a possible way to treat
gynecomastia or "bitch tits" in men and I know you recommend flax
oil losing fat and general health also. Would flax have equal
benefits for athletic women like me who lift weights and do you
still think it helps with gyno?
14 Causes of Constipation
Written by: Howard Richman |
Distributed: 2008-12-02 |
Word Count: 1642 |
Page Views: 8530
| Votes: 9 |
Rating: 3.00
For people who know all about drinking liquids and eating fiber
but still have never been able to break free of their curse of
constipation, this article offers many other considerations that
will help the reader find solutions to lifelong constipation.
How to Force Your Body To Melt Fat Like Butter In A Microwave
Written by: Robert Kokoska |
Distributed: 2008-04-08 |
Word Count: 613 |
Page Views: 7416
| Votes: 22 |
Rating: 2.77
There are a couple of very simple changes you can make to the way
you eat that will force your body to become a fat burning furnace
and cause you to easily drop your unwanted pounds day after day.
Highest Ranked "Health And Wellness" Articles
The Role of Antioxidants in Good Health And Healthy Living
Written by: Cheryll Rice |
Distributed: 2008-01-24 |
Word Count: 718 |
Page Views: 1344
| Votes: 5 |
Rating: 4.20
Everyone has heard about the importance of a balanced diet for
maintaining good health. Similarly, everyone knows that they
should be getting exercise - or at the very least adding more
activity into their days. Getting a good night's sleep is
essential - without it, you'll find that your immune system
starts to slack off a bit and you put yourself at a greater risk
for catching a cold or coming down with the flu. We all know what
we should be doing, but let's be honest: we don't do it...
What Makes Tea So Effective At Preventing Heart Disease?
Written by: Jon M. Stout |
Distributed: 2007-02-02 |
Word Count: 812 |
Page Views: 1542
| Votes: 7 |
Rating: 4.00
Many bodies of research have shown that tea is effective at
preventing heart disease in several ways. Tea prevents the
oxidation of LDL cholesterol into plaque, the hard substance that
clogs our arteries, making us more susceptible to heart attacks
and strokes. Tea is also thought to have an anti-inflammatory
effect, which helps the heart in its overall function.
Which Full Face CPAP Mask is Best for You?
Written by: Chris Vasta |
Distributed: 2009-09-01 |
Word Count: 690 |
Page Views: 3639
| Votes: 10 |
Rating: 4.00
If you've been diagnosed with Sleep Apnea, you are
undoubtedly trying to narrow the choice of masks. If your
mouth opens during sleep, one option would be full face CPAP
masks. The full face CPAP mask is used to deliver pressure
through both the nose and mouth. Trying to decide which full
face CPAP mask to use can be complex and expensive. The
number of mask options available is confounding. Based upon
comfort, fit, good seal, and durability, we recommend the
following three full face CPAP masks.
Neurotransmitter Testing: How It Help Depression, Anxiety and More
Written by: Anne Arthur |
Distributed: 2006-08-03 |
Word Count: 663 |
Page Views: 2211
| Votes: 7 |
Rating: 3.86
Millions of people suffer from bipolar disorder, anxiety, panic
attacks, depression and ADD/ADHD without a known cause. If you or
someone you know suffers from anxiety, bipolar disorder,
depression, mania, ADD/ADHD or even panic attacks, you owe it to
you to find the real cause of your problem. There are many
natural treatments available that effectively combat these
diseases.
Concocting the Perfect Body Detox Plan
Written by: John Khu |
Distributed: 2009-04-21 |
Word Count: 588 |
Page Views: 1236
| Votes: 7 |
Rating: 3.86
If you have recently made a committed resolve to stick to a body
detox program, then it is best to get very well prepared for it.
Otherwise, you might catch yourself doing some last-minute
enjoyment and drowning yourself in your favorite food and drinks.
Want To Try Body Detox?
Written by: John Khu |
Distributed: 2009-08-25 |
Word Count: 595 |
Page Views: 977
| Votes: 7 |
Rating: 3.86
Ever since more and more people became aware of the harmful
effects of improper diet and toxins to the body, body
detoxification also became very popular. Although it is a
fact that the body can detoxify by itself, it is also a fact
that without the initiative of a person's mind to reinforce
more action aside from the organs' functions, then the
detoxification process will take a long time, or worse, not
work at all.
Heavier Weight Sometimes Equals Smaller Jeans
Written by: Kamau Austin |
Distributed: 2007-02-07 |
Word Count: 1005 |
Page Views: 1589
| Votes: 6 |
Rating: 3.83
A concept many women sometimes have difficulty understanding is
that a smaller weight does not always indicate a fitter body.
Muscle mass is more dense than fat tissue. This means two women
of the same height, weight, skeletal structure and body type may
look drastically different.
Get a Great Night's Sleep
Written by: George Esser |
Distributed: 2007-05-15 |
Word Count: 597 |
Page Views: 1311
| Votes: 6 |
Rating: 3.83
Reasons why we need magnesium supplements to get a great night's
sleep. Research points to reduced restless leg syndrome and other
sleep disorders.
Colon Cancer: Risks and Prevention
Written by: Abel Travers |
Distributed: 2007-12-13 |
Word Count: 785 |
Page Views: 1096
| Votes: 5 |
Rating: 3.80
Cancer: it's not a word that anyone really wants to hear. While
not necessarily a death sentence, cancer is an illness that does
have a high mortality rate depending on where in the body it
strikes. Read on as we examine what can be done to head-off Colon
Cancer, the third most common cancer.
Green Tea May Positively Effect Stomach Cancer in Habitual Tea Drinkers
Written by: Jon M. Stout |
Distributed: 2006-11-06 |
Word Count: 535 |
Page Views: 1234
| Votes: 9 |
Rating: 3.78
Stomach Cancer is the second-leading cause of cancer-related
deaths in the Western World. In fact, the American Cancer
Society estimates that 22,228 Americans will be diagnosed with
stomach cancer during 2006. They also project that there will be
an estimated 11,430 deaths from this type of disease. Therefore,
the search for a cure for this disease has been a long standing
one. In the past, clinical researchers have hypothesized that
drinking green tea may indeed inhibit stomach carcinogenesis,
and a few case-studies with animals and human beings have
successfully broadened this theory.
|
|
|
Article Reprint Rights
|
This work is
licensed under a
Creative Commons
License
You are not required to show the creative commons license notice when you reprint this work.
|
|
Article Statistics
|
Word Count: 1821
Total Views: 2409
Views This Month: 74
Views Last Month: 109
Article Rating: 3.79 of 5
Votes Cast: 14
Author Overall Stats:
Times Viewed Overall: 2405
Author Rating: 3.28 of 5
Votes Cast Overall: 18
More Articles By Author:
Articles On This Website
Article Title Search:
Widow Search
Right Blinker
Google
Yahoo!
Zuula
Bing
Cuil
Last Distribution Date:
2009-09-30 12:12:00
|
|
|
Home
for Writers
for Publishers
Article Directory
Article Search
Contact
Get RSS Feed
